From: Mathieu.Ouellet@dfo-mpo.gc.ca Subject: RE: RE: CTD April 2011 processing notes for GTSPP profiles To: Melanie.Hamilton@noaa.gov cc: Anh.Tran@dfo-mpo.gc.ca Date: 8/2/2011 12:56 PM Dear Melanie Attached is a file with corrections for Q9900258, Q9900262, Q9900293 and JLOV ("D" for all selected). I didn't use the automatic system so I have to send this file manually. I'll wait to hear more from SMRU/BODC before deleting more seals Regards Mathieu -----Original Message----- From: Melanie.Hamilton@noaa.gov [mailto:Melanie.Hamilton@noaa.gov] Sent: July 29, 2011 4:37 PM To: Ouellet, Mathieu Cc: Tran, Anh; Meilin.Chen@noaa.gov; Charles.Sun@noaa.gov; Ricardo Locarnini Subject: Re: RE: CTD April 2011 processing notes for GTSPP profiles (1) DBID is the Unique Database ID in the GTSPP CMD here at NODC. It's generated at our end. (2) I attached a file showing the cruise track and you can see those that are on LAND....there are approximately 9 - 10 profiles on LAND. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Ouellet, Mathieu" Date: Friday, July 29, 2011 3:29 pm Subject: RE: CTD April 2011 processing notes for GTSPP profiles > > Hi Melanie > > > > (1)There was indeed a suspicious interchange between FZVN and FVNM, > > but I'm not sure whether FZVN or FVNM is the right call sign for > > this cruise. The "Tara", FVNM, is not listed in the "2010 French > > oceanographic cruises report" (Ifremer), yet it reported 137 TESACs > > in 2010. On the other hand, the "Le Suroî, FZVN, was active in > > 2010 according to the catalog, yet no TESACs were reported as FZVN > > in 2010. > > > > It could be a bigger problem; ie, someone has been using the wrong > > call sign for a whole year or so. I just wrote to Loic Petit de la > > Villeon at Ifremer to ask him to help me clarify this. > > > > (2)I will flag "SHIP 11" station "9950" as duplicate > > > > (3)No points are on land, I exported the points in a KML file > > (attached; the numbers refer to the MKEY column), and Google's > > bathymetry reveals that no point is on land, though several are in > > coastal embayments. As for the repetition of stations, I think they > > are probably following a pattern of 35 stations every month for > > monitoring purposes. I don't see anything wrong with this ship > > track. Please let me know if I'm still missing something. > > > > Regards > > > > Mathieu > > > > PS: What is a DBID ? > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Melanie Hamilton [mailto:Melanie.Hamilton@noaa.gov] > > Sent: July 26, 2011 11:15 AM > > To: Tran, Anh; Ouellet, Mathieu > > Cc: Meilin.Chen@noaa.gov; Charles.Sun@noaa.gov; Ricardo Locarnini > > Subject: CTD April 2011 processing notes for GTSPP profiles > > > > > > Anh and Mathieu, > > > > The GTSPP receives feedback from the Ocean Climate Lab here at > > NODC > > (Ricardo Locarnini and Tim Boyer), > > and I am reviewing these notes, and putting together only where I > > think > > that updates, replacements, and or > > deletes should probably come from your end. > > > > Ricardo did provide us with a list of callsigns for review, and we > > are > > working on those....but he's also suggested > > possible updates to cruise tracks and he's also identified > > potential > > duplicates......so here we go.... > > > > (1) Ricardo noted: > > Data under call sign FZVN, 18 and 19 March 2011 could actually > > belong > > to call sign FVNM. > > > > ===== > > What I have found.....is > > 2 different shipnames for these callsigns, yet it looks as though > > both > > callsigns fit together as one cruise track. > > > > http://www.itu.int/online/mms/mars/ship_detail.sh > > Particulars - Ship Name: TARA > > Administration : France > > Geo. Area : France > > Ship Name : TARA > > Call Sign : FVNM > > > > http://shipping-data.com/ship/tara-v > > TARA V > > IMO: 8817552 > > Call Sign: FVNM > > DWT: > > Build: 1989 > > Ship Type: Oceanographic/Research > > Flag: France > > > > http://e-ships.net/ships.htm > > Ship name Ship type DWT Built Flag > > Tara Oceanographic/Research 1989 France > > > > http://www.itu.int/online/mms/mars/ship_search.sh > > Particulars - Ship Name: LE SUROIT > > Administration : France > > Geo. Area : France > > Ship Name : LE SUROIT > > Call Sign : FZVN > > > > http://e-ships.net/ships.htm > > Ship name Ship type DWT Built Flag > > Le Suroit Oceanographic/Research 356 1975 France > > > > > > http://www.vesseltracker.com/en/Ships/Le-Suroit-7360368.html > > Le Suroit (IMO: 7360368) > > Type of ship: Other Ship > > IMO Number: 7360368 Flag: France > > MMSI Number: 227223000 Length: 56.0m > > Callsign: FZVN Beam: 11.0m > > > > > > I will attach file "FZVN_FVNM_mar2011.meds" for you to review. > > Don't > > worry if you disagree.....I don't know > > how best to tackle this unless we contact someone in France. > > > > =============================== > > > > (2) DBID duplicated pairs in the GTSPP CTD data > > First column removed, second column kept in the WODB. > > > > 11165002 11165001 > > > > What I found is that I agree with Ricardo.....and said that I > > would > > send an email to MEDS asking > > you to mark this station as a duplicate "SHIP 11 BA 9950". > > I > > will send you a file to review, > > "potential_dups.meds". > > > > SQL> select * from station where station = 11165002; > > > > STATION ONESQ CRUISEID OBSY OB OB OBST DA IUMSGNO S U > > STNNUMBE---------- -------- ---------- ---- -- -- ---- -- ---------- > > -- - - -------- > > LATITUDE LONGITUDE Q Q Q UP_DATE BULTIME BULHEA SOUR STRE > > QCVE D > > NO NP NS > > -------- --------- - - - -------- ------------ ------ ---- ---- ---- > > - > > -- -- -- > > NUM LOADEPOCH A D OC > > --- --------- - - -- > > 11165002 44125 SHIP 11 2011 02 20 0642 BA 172261 I U > > 9950 > > 34.0000 -137.0000 1 1 1 20110221 201102210543 SOVX01 RJTD MEBA > > 1.3 A > > 1 0 8 > > 8 22-FEB-11 Y R PA > > > > > > SQL> select * from station where station = 11165001; > > > > STATION ONESQ CRUISEID OBSY OB OB OBST DA IUMSGNO S U > > STNNUMBE---------- -------- ---------- ---- -- -- ---- -- ---------- > > -- - - -------- > > LATITUDE LONGITUDE Q Q Q UP_DATE BULTIME BULHEA SOUR STRE > > QCVE D > > NO NP NS > > -------- --------- - - - -------- ------------ ------ ---- ---- ---- > > - > > -- -- -- > > NUM LOADEPOCH A D OC > > --- --------- - - -- > > 11165001 44125 JLOV 11 2011 02 20 0642 BA 172261 I U > > 9955 > > 34.0000 -137.0000 1 1 1 20110221 201102210543 SOVX01 RJTD MEBA > > 1.3 A > > 1 0 9 > > 8 22-FEB-11 Y R PA > > > > abalone_ > cat 11165001.meds 11165002.meds > potential_dups.meds > > > > ========================================= > > > > (3) DBID's for call sign JDWE, 12 January 2011, 2 February 2011, > > and 3 March 2011, have serious track/ship speed errors. > > > > > > I do find that I agree with Ricardo. It looks as though there is > > data > > on LAND, and > > the cruise of January is repeated exactly again in February....and > > again in March. I have attached a file for you to review, and > > perhaps > > to re-QC > > "JDWE_janmar2011.meds" > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >